← Back to all episodes

Everyone’s flat right now (not just you)

Nat and Kristen dig into the motivation gap that’s showing up everywhere right now – teams low on initiative, leaders exhausted by it, and nobody quite sure why. They cover a few reasons people are checked out (spoiler: six years of economic chaos can do that), why change fatigue is different this time, and whether the generational blame game is actually useful.

Plus: why running faster is not the answer, and the case for doing absolutely nothing in your 15-minute gaps instead of doom-scrolling.

Dive deeper:
No, self-sacrifice isn’t a virtue
Confusing hard work with burnout?

Read the full transcript

Kristen: We get the absolute pleasure of chatting to, oh my gosh, tens of women each week. I was going to say hundreds. Some weeks it is hundreds, but on average it’s tens. There seems to be a time of year, or some common themes, or some new and interesting themes that have emerged. So I thought I’d share what I’ve been hearing with Nat, and that you’re going to share a common thing with me. We’ll see where we land. I think it’ll probably dictate a couple of podcast episodes. But first, any interesting or random updates from you, Nat?

Nat: Well, before we started, did you just prod yourself in the eye with your glasses?

Kristen: No, I’m good. I’m just getting them on so I look a bit pristine.

Nat: Kristen put lipstick on before we started recording, because we keep threatening to put out the video of these and then we freak ourselves out. We’re literally sitting here in home clothes and probably unrecognizable. I remember in the episode where I said one of my work peeves was people who use a photo that’s 20 years old. If people ever see us on a stage and then podcasting, they’ll say, are those the same two people? Anyway, I didn’t put on lipstick and I don’t look amazing today, because I just ran up a mountain. I ran up Mount Victoria. Not the full way. We had to drop the dog off to fail his adoption test, and I ran to the top from there with a few walking breaks, but not many. I was very impressed with myself.

Kristen: Good on you!

Nat: That was my excuse. It was also my way of humble bragging and throwing you under the bus with the lipstick.

Kristen: There was nothing humble about any of that.

Nat: It’s like passive aggressive, except I just remove the first word and go with the guts of it.

Kristen: Exactly.

Nat: But we all just had a long weekend, and it was a nice one. Did you have a good weekend?

Kristen: I was just saying to my friend this morning, who I chat with on most of my dog walks, that I’m in an unhelpful loop of not sleeping well, so I’m tired and don’t get myself to do proper cardio or weight lifting, and then because I don’t do that, I don’t sleep well. It’s an awful cycle. I’ve got a session tomorrow morning and I’m going to reset, which is great, because you can always start fresh.

Nat: I still have a box of melatonin for you. I need to give it to you. Did I tell you they brought back two boxes for you, and then I gave Mum a couple of our gummies to try and she said, I think I’m going to keep one of these boxes?

Kristen: They work!

Nat: She’s probably like you when it comes to sleeping. She really struggles to get to sleep. When I was a teenager she used to wear a big white nightie, and we’d come home and she’d look like a ghost wandering around the house at night. You will get some melatonin. But yes, it’s a terrible cycle, isn’t it?

Kristen: Terrible, but I did get up and walk. I have to tell one random story about my walk this morning. It’s short, and it’s for all our allies listening, or anyone who can pass this message on to allies. When you’re a woman walking alone in the bush, all sorts of risks go through your head, because you’re going into a relatively deserted part of the city. Granted, I’ve got a dog and I walk my dog. But she isn’t a German Shepherd or a Rottweiler. Juno is a cocker spaniel and not super threatening. I have no idea how she’d react to a threat, and I can’t imagine I’d be all that safe. So I like chatting on my dog walks for safety’s sake. Nonetheless, it’s something unfortunate that women deal with when we go on walks. So who do I encounter?

Nat: Can I say very quickly, I’ve seen the hashtag “not all men”, and there was a thing on Instagram recently. If you were given 10 Big Macs, and one in every 10 was a rotting, stinking mess, but you didn’t know which one, would you eat any of them? People say no. That’s how women feel walking alone in places like this. Nine out of 10 people are fine, but you don’t want to risk the one, and you can’t tell which one it is.

Kristen: And statistically you have to go and live anyway, but we are putting ourselves at risk. In my twenties I lived in Vancouver, in a part of the city that wasn’t all that safe, and I’d walk right down the middle of the street where the streetlights hit. You get used to that. So halfway through my walk in the bush this morning, two kilometers in, I come across a single guy. Right away that’s not a great feeling. Normally it’s a quick check of the eyes and then you move on. But I noticed his T-shirt had a picture of a woman on it, with big red words at the top that said “the Manson massacres.” It was like a one-on-one class on how to look as threatening as humanly possible. Why would you go on a morning walk wearing a shirt about a massacre?

Nat: I think it’s privilege. I don’t know this for sure, but from talking to a bunch of men in my life, it has never occurred to them that walking alone in the bush is anything other than a pleasant thing to do. They find it truly shocking to realize that for 50% of the population it’s top of mind the entire time. I’m yet to meet a woman who’s carefree walking through the bush. He’s probably completely oblivious to how threatening that looks. Men often do silly things because they’re not aware of it either. They stop and stare, or slow down, or follow you closely, and you think, threat, threat.

Kristen: I look behind for at least five minutes. So my actionable advice for men walking in the bush: grab your My Little Pony, your Care Bears, your Pac-Man, a rainbows-and-butterflies T-shirt. Just a T-shirt that tells me you aren’t a mass murderer, thank you very much.

Nat: Or don’t support mass murder. And while you’re here, there are some really good cues you can give. I really appreciate men who smile, wave and step out of the way. There are men who glare at you, men who walk directly into your path, men who walk very slowly behind you. If you’re thinking about how to make this as comfortable as possible for someone who probably feels quite threatened right now, do those things. It generally means defusing the situation, because I guarantee that if you come across a random woman alone in the bush, she’ll be assuming you’re going to murder her. That’s probably a shock for a lot of men, but it’s true.

Kristen: Especially when you’re wearing a Manson T-shirt. Anyway, that’s my random story, but I want to chat about a key theme. Do you want to start, or shall I?

Nat: You start.

Kristen: This is a chat I’ve had with a bunch of people in the last week, and I think it’s relatively universal at the moment. If you work in an organization, many people are feeling flat right now. They’re saying they feel overworked, possibly under-appreciated. They feel the increasing volume of the role, the classic “do more with less.” As a result, some behaviors have come out that are increasingly noticeable and very concerning for a number of the women I’ve been speaking with. I’ll clarify, it’s nothing dangerous, based on the previous chat.

Nat: No one’s wearing Manson family murders T-shirts.

Kristen: These are leaders who take their roles very seriously, work really hard, appreciate that a lot is going on, and are locked in and taking ownership. What they’ve noticed is a motivation gap. That’s how I’d classify it, and it’s showing up as ownership and initiative at rock bottom. If there are problems to solve, they’re either not seen, or people don’t take responsibility for solving them, or they come to their leaders with problems rather than saying, I’ve noticed this, here’s what I think we should do, or offering a suggestion for where to from here. So there’s a lack of ownership and initiative, and some questions about why. A few theories have come up. Some relate to people feeling stuck right now, because there isn’t a lot of work out there and they can’t move on. Other people point to generational conversations. Is there something there? That seems to be a key thing.

Nat: I’m going to start with something. We talk a lot about problems versus solutions. I think we need to change it to complaints versus solutions, because if you come with a really good problem to solve, great. But if you come just complaining about everything, not great. We use the terminology interchangeably, so somewhere along the line we’ll fix that. I agree with you. In an economy where the general consensus is to cling to your job if you’ve got it, there’s a real fear of redundancies. I think that’s the case globally, because every time we talk to people in different countries, or people visit, it’s the same doom and gloom everywhere. These things are comparative. Even if some countries are in a worse state than others, if the people around you feel like things have gone backwards, you’ll feel that too. There’s also the ongoing cost of living crisis. We have fabulous friends who work in finance, and their big message at the moment is that if you’re worried about paying your bills and have financial instability, you can’t turn up at work and say, whoa, I’m here! Anytime you’re coming from a place of fear or stress, you’re not going to be operating at your best. We’re hypothesizing here, but the extra thing this time is how long it’s been going on. I remember the GFC. Granted, New Zealand was less badly hit than a lot of other countries, and I worked in tech, so I was the opposite of badly affected in many ways, but that was about 18 months before we saw a real recovery. This has been a W shape: lots of growth, then COVID, then it felt like we were coming out of it, then we dropped back down, then it felt like we might be lifting up again, and then the Iran war and the oil crisis started to hit. There’s no light at the end of the tunnel, and it’s been going on for about six years. That’s a long time for people to feel like it’s tough and to not see green shoots that aren’t being mowed down by the next crisis.

Kristen: I think so. I’d add a couple of extra things, some overlapping. The first is that big projects, big deliverables and expectations of big delivery are relentless. Historically you’d have a big build-up, deliver something, and take a beat. Now it’s, you’re on the next project, now we’ve got to do this. I feel comfortable in that environment, but I’m not convinced that’s the case for a lot of people and organizations that had a bit of extra padding, or space to celebrate, or downtime. So I think it’s relentless. That’s number one.

Nat: Can I dig into that before you move on? We talk a lot about the rise of AI and how it’s going to take jobs. What you’re describing is that it’s already here. The reality of working in that world is that work gets faster and more relentless. We’re already seeing that with automation and AI. My example is marketing. Back in the day, you could do one big ad campaign, and it would be about six months of work. Now you’ve got Instagram and you’re putting out 10 reels a day. The quantity of output has grown exponentially. That’s the busyness of the world now. You can’t win marketing with one ad campaign a quarter or every six months anymore. You have to win it with 10X to 100X the output. If you take that analogy to every other piece of work, any organization working at a pace that was fine 10 years ago is not going to succeed, unless it’s upskilling, changing platforms and processes, and accepting that this is how work has to go. It’s a really hard mindset change, but it becomes a bit easier when you realize it’s not just me doing it, it’s an augmented me. I now have tools that, if I use them well, mean I can increase my capacity substantially without increasing burnout or stress, and maybe lower it a bit.

Kristen: Possibly. Which brings me to a second point that you’ve introduced nicely, and that’s change. There used to be a new system or process, some form of change you’d work on, and then the change would be over. What’s happened is that change is relentless, and people almost expect that after this tool, this process change, this restructure, everything will go back to normal. I got thinking, how do you tell people that change is here to stay? Environments in the past that didn’t change, or failed to change, will effectively be out of business in due course. So how do we create resilient, optimistic people who see that as an opportunity rather than a stage that will be over? This is the whole “Who Moved My Cheese?” question. How do we embed that a little?

Nat: I wish we had a time capsule, because whenever we have these conversations I wonder, if we went back 10 years, would we have been complaining about the same things? I think we have very short memories. When times are good, we don’t recognize that they’re good either. We look back and say those were simpler times, but in the moment, humans find it very hard to acknowledge that. We tell ourselves it used to be so good, I used to be so much less busy, it used to be so much more certain, and now it’s really bad. And I wonder, did we feel that at the time? When you look back with hindsight, what happened is 100% certain, so it feels nicely tied up in a bow. But during those times there was also uncertainty and change. We’re just not looking at it through that lens anymore.

Kristen: I also wonder if it’s that the way we work is constantly changing. Back then, you could foreshadow what your year might look like, you’d have your KPIs, you’d go and deliver, you’d have your 9 to 5 or 9 to 7. But technology is moving so quickly that systems are constantly being upgraded, and how we communicate is constantly being upgraded. If we look back a decade ago, Slack was probably just being introduced. There’s been an immense amount of technological change in the last decade, and we’ve had to keep up with it. I think the pace is like the speed of processors, there’s a chart on that, and I suspect there’s a similar chart for technological advancement in the workplace. That’s why we now have entire roles called transformation. “I’m a transformation manager” wouldn’t have been a thing before.

Nat: I know people listen to Power Up for the conspiracy theories, so I’ll give you one for free. I’m hearing more and more rumblings from billionaires that it probably doesn’t make sense to have two people working, and that when we have all our automation and robots in place, we can go back to a wonderful world where one parent stays at home with the kids and the other works. Of course, we know that’s not true, because they’re not altruistic folk here to make the world a better place. They’ve figured out how to cut half the workforce and keep all the profits to themselves. It scarily aligns with the rollback to more traditional gender stereotypes that we’re seeing all over the place. So there’s an argument that organizations have very little motivation to make it feel easy for us all to be working, because it’s in their best interest to cut headcount and get the robots to do it.

Kristen: It’s a great theory, and I know there are a bunch out there, and some are scary. Others say it won’t be as serious as we think, because frankly my robot sucks and lies to me all the time.

Nat: Oh, mine too. But as a grounded optimist, I think we lack imagination about what’s possible going forward. At every significant step in human history, no one could imagine what came next. The classic is, if you asked people what they wanted, they’d say a faster horse. We couldn’t imagine what a car might look like. I saw something the other day about drones. As bad as war is, the war in Ukraine has led to so much innovation in drones that it’s no longer sci-fi to think personalized one-to-five-person transport will become possible. Only a couple of hundred years ago, the concept of a car seemed outlandish. So we’ll probably make a giant jump forward, and every time that happens, more jobs, and different jobs, and different ways of doing things are created. I don’t think it’s all doom and gloom, but we’re unfortunately positioned in the almost-transformation stage, moving from one type of economy to another. We’re going to feel the unfair burden of that change. Your kids and the kids behind them will have five or 10 years of this and then enter a new workforce with maybe not more certainty, but slightly different ways of working. Whereas we’re trying to juggle the old ways, the new ways and the new new ways, and it’s exhausting.

Kristen: You’ve led nicely to my third and final point. Thank you so much. This is an entirely different podcast episode, so I don’t think we should dig into it, but it’s what I alluded to earlier: a key underlying factor in the motivation gap may be generational. We’ve got someone coming up in Powrsuit later in June to talk about the different generations and values, and when those get locked in.

Nat: So you should join. It’s for members only.

Kristen: So join to get it live, or on demand after the fact. I’ve also got a podcast I haven’t listened to yet, Simon Sinek speaking with someone else. I’ve got it open and I’m going to watch it. Then I suggest we tackle some interesting generational chats, Nat.

Nat: I get all my information from Instagram, and my favorite recent one on generations was a Gen Alpha or Gen Z person saying, you boomers think we’re the most fragile generation, but you people were terrified of drinking from the same tap as a Black person. They said, you were the most fragile. You were scared of all sorts of things, and now you look at us, and we’re pretty robust, healthy, open-minded people.

Kristen: I love it. Thank you for entertaining my theme. Have you got a theme, Nat?

Nat: I think you’ve clocked it. I do think there’s a point you get to at a certain stage of career and life. I’m surrounded by parents whose kids are entering or exiting their teen years. They’re at pretty good stages in their careers, earning pretty good money, and in that group there’s a sense of optimism, and of not being controlled by the uncontrollables. They say, there’s going to be non-stop change and all the stuff we’ve talked about, but I’m going to go with it. I’m not going to fight or resist it, because I can’t, and I’ve been through it enough times to know that. Find opportunities where you see them, take breaks when you can, and realize work isn’t always the be-all and end-all. If you can’t control what’s happening in the moment, go and do other things and invest in other parts of your life. That tends to be the case in my bubble. But I’ve noticed the exact same thing you have, a real sense of inertia, of, I don’t know what to do, I’m being asked to change all the time. Even for anyone listening who’s not in Wellington, New Zealand: our government announced a week or two ago that it wants to take government headcount down to 1% of the population from 1.2%, and the justification was AI. In my opinion, they did exactly what every board and leadership team is doing at the moment, saying “AI will solve it” without any frameworks, training or evidence of how it can be used well in organizations. They’ll probably spend a fortune on consultants. But the conversation around it is really interesting. I personally believe governments and leaders should make bold calls, and that’s something we really struggle with in a small country with a three-year election cycle, where no one’s incentivized to think 100 years ahead. They’re thinking about the next election. I’m a proponent of making well-thought-through bets on the future. What I find interesting is that the pushback is all, what about me, what about my job? I completely agree that on an individual level this is going to be really tough for a lot of people, absolutely. And we also have to start having these conversations at a macro level: is this going to be good for us in 20, 50, 100 years? We’re entering a world with aging populations and money flowing differently. So from the themes we’ve both spotted, I think it’s a good opportunity to stretch and think big picture. Putting the short-term pain aside, how might this end up better? Transformation is always tricky. If we lose a lot of public servants, they’re talking about 10,000 in a city of about 500,000 people. My dream in 10 to 20 years is that we’re not a government town. We’re a tech town that has government here, and you have to work towards that. All of that waffle to say, it’s a very hard time to get out of your own head and your own struggle, because those struggles are very real. It’s also a time to think about what the world looks like in 100 years, because I guarantee it’s not going to look like this. If we don’t start taking action now, doing things differently and getting comfortable working in different ways, you’re the person who’s left behind. The change is happening anyway.

Kristen: I agree. I think we’d all benefit from self-awareness and curiosity, taking stock of what’s going on and what’s changed. It’s probably a season of self-awareness: why am I feeling this way right now? When I asked a lot of these people whether workloads were higher, their perception was that they weren’t, but that the work projects were big and complex. So complexity has increased, relentlessness has increased, and, like you said, the adoption of new things has increased.

Nat: Five years ago people went fully remote, then rolled it back to fully in-office or partially in-office, and haven’t redesigned work to suit. There are all these poor practices that put a huge mental load and time load on all of us, and we have our rants about this, and they don’t have any real impact on productivity. The note I’d leave on, and you can leave on another note: on Friday I’d just got out of the car to meet my friend who’s just had a baby and my friend who’s about to have a baby. We said, let’s take an hour at lunchtime. I don’t know if I’ve talked about this on the podcast, but I had a couple of weeks where my calendar wasn’t crammed with events and meetings. Then you called me, walking in somewhere, saying “I don’t feel guilty,” which was hilarious. The lesson I took from you not feeling guilty but calling me to tell me so, and me going out at lunchtime while you thought about going surfing and not having a max-productive week, is that in times like this it’s more important than ever to recognize that running as fast as possible is the fastest way to burn out and not much else. You’re not more productive, you’re not getting more done, and you’re not adding more value to the world. You have to take breaks, recalibrate and think about the right next thing to do, and that doesn’t come from running, running, running. If you’re feeling overwhelmed, give yourself permission to realize that life exists outside the big scary stressful stuff. It’s okay to read a book, go for a walk, and meet someone who loves the Manson murders with your dog.

Kristen: I do love that, except for the last part. My little tip, and I think I sent you this reel yesterday: we have more time than we did 18 months ago.

Nat: All the time, and it keeps improving, I think.

Kristen: That’s right, because of our dumb robots. We have more time, which doesn’t feel like it. What was interesting about the research is that while we may have more of it in total, it’s chunked up more than ever. We’ve got 10 minutes here, 15 minutes there, five minutes, half an hour. What we tend to do, and we do a whole mini masterclass on this, is not rest or breathe or take deliberate micro breaks. We scroll, we watch the news, and it’s a relentless wave of information into our brains. That’s a whole other session, so become a Powrsuiter if you want help with that. But it’s interesting to think about. We have more time, just in tiny chunks, so be self-aware about how you’re using them.

Nat: If we leave behind all the influencers and the Bitcoin bros who are now AI bros, depending on who you speak to you’ll hear very different answers about having more time. I have friends who’ve really adopted AI in their day-to-day life, as have we, and we get a lot more done. I wouldn’t say I’m working any harder than I was five years ago. Maybe some of the divide, and the sense of relentlessness, is because some people are augmenting their work and using tools to get a lot more done in a lot less time. If you’re not using those tools, it feels like you’re falling behind, because you are. You can’t do 10X or 2X or even 0.5 more than you used to be able to do, and that’s going to become a bigger divide. So, a plug for Powrsuit: we weave AI into most of what we do now, like going to your robot to help you prioritize or manage your calendar, and we give tips for that. We’re also going to run a couple of totally judgment-free sessions, where you don’t assume you know anything at all. Get your robot set up properly, address the things Powrsuiters care about like keeping privacy up to date, think about the ethical side, set a tool up so it knows you a little, and start using it. If you’re feeling like, argh, I guarantee there are ways to get out of that a little. Even if you’re doing everything perfectly, it’s worth stopping and asking, is there anything else I could be doing? Maybe there’s a slightly different way of working.

Kristen: On that note, check out powrsuit.com and let us know how you’re going, even on this chat. We’d love to hear if you’re feeling busier than you used to, or generally how you’re going. Reach out, we’d love to chat.

Nat: I don’t have an etymology today. Have you?

Kristen: No, but I want to chat influencers next episode, so let’s put a pin in it.

Nat: Okay, I’ll find some etymologies. I like that word.

Kristen: All right, catch y’all next time, everyone.

Both: Bye!

You may also like these episodes...

Get bite-sized career development, straight to your inbox

Bite-sized career development, straight to your inbox